Philanthropy
Impact Investors Expect More AuM; Raise Concerns About "Mission Drift" As Big Players Enter The Fray
Impact investing is one of the strong trends in wealth management, and more money is being put to work in this space. There are some concerns, however, as a global study shows.
The arrival of larger firms into the space known as impact
investing raises the risk that money managers will drift away
from the core of what this sort of asset management is meant to
achieve, a study of the sector shows.
The cautionary note was raised by a survey from the Global
Impact Investing Network, a pan-industry group gathering data
on the sector and prosletysing about the investment model. More
positively, the study, which covers an array of groups including
wealth managers and family offices, said investors ntend to boost
capital to this style of asset management by 17 per cent this
year, reaching $25.9 billion this year, covering 9,557 deals.
The impact investing field has become increasingly visible as a
wealth management talking point, tapping into a desire among high
net worth individuals to use their wealth to improve the
environment, tackle poverty and poor education, and other
objectives. The process is, its practitioners argue, not at odds
with hard-nosed pursuit of investment returns because investing
for "good" equates to smart practice anyway.
GIIN survyed 209 organisations, reporting a total of $114 billion
in impact investing assets under management. Survey participants
committed a total of $22.1 billion in 7,951 impact investment
deals in 2016.
Fund managers raised $11.1 billion in 2016, with plans to raise
$18.5 billion in 2017, the report showed.
Investors who responded to the survey reported that returns met
or exceeded their expectations in both impact (98 per cent) and
financial performance (91 per cent).
Among details of the report, it showed that there have been an
"increasing number of large, well-known asset managers and other
financial firms entering the impact investing space". In 2015,
for example, the world's largest listed asset manager, BlackRock,
said it was throwing its weight behind the impact investing
space. Goldman Sachs and Bank of America are involved in areas
such as social impact bonds; banks including UBS have created
impact investing funds.
Mission drift
The arrival of large firms will "help professionalise the market,
bring in much-needed capital, and enhance the credibility of
impact investing", the report continued, but there is the risk
that arrival of prominent players will cause "mission drift" - in
other words, that the original idealism of impact investing will
be undermined in a chase for returns.
Investors reported progress on a number of factors, including an
increasing abundance of professionals with relevant skillsets (90
per cent noted progress) and greater availability of market
research and data on products and performance (89 per cent
reported progress).
About 26 per cent of respondents track their impact investment
performance to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
and another 34 per cent plan to do so in the near future. The
SDGs have served as a rallying cry for many impact investors to
link their investments to a broader international initiative.
Respondents to the study measure the social and/or environmental
performance of their impact investments, using a mix of
proprietary metrics, qualitative information, IRIS-aligned
metrics, and other tools and frameworks.
The top sectors to which respondents allocated capital were
housing, energy, and microfinance. Top geographies of investment
were the US & Canada, Europe, sub-Saharan Africa, and Latin
America & the Caribbean.
While two out of three respondents target risk-adjusted, market
rates of return, there was broad agreement among respondents that
below-market-rate capital plays a valuable role in impact
investing. Roughly four out of five respondents agreed that this
type of capital has several benefits, including its ability to
mitigate risk of investments to attract new investors, act as a
bridge between philanthropy and market-rate capital, and
capitalize opportunities that may never lend themselves to
risk-adjusted returns.