Tax
HMRC Raid Two English Clubs For Alleged Tax Fraud
The HMRC has raided a number of premises in England as well as in France.
Two of English football’s most high-profile football clubs
have been raided by the HMRC on suspected Income Tax
and National Insurance fraud.
The premises of Newcastle United, Sports Direct Arena, and
West Ham United, London Stadium, were entered by officials
yesterday after HMRC, the UK tax authority, said in a
statement it had searched premises in the Northeast and
Southeast of England as well as in France.
French authorities assisted with the UK investigation, as 180
HMRC offices have been deployed across the UK and France. Rush
Green, West Ham's training ground and Newcastle's Darsely Park
training facility were also raided. According to the
HMRC: “several men have been arrested working within the
professional football industry” and investigators have “arrested
the men and also seized business records, financial records,
computers and mobiles phones”.
“This criminal investigation sends a clear message that, whoever
you are, if you commit tax fraud you can expect to face the
consequences. As this is an ongoing investigation HMRC is unable
to provide any further detail at this time,” HMRC added.
Yesterday, a statement from the French authorities said:
"April 26, 2017, a number of arrests and searches were carried
out in France in connection with the execution by the national
financial prosecutor (PNF) of a request on July 29, 2016, for
mutual assistance from the British judicial authorities.Ten
searches were carried out all over France and four people were
held in custody. Documents were also seized.
"The investigation is being conducted by Her Majesty's Revenue
and Customs (HMRC). It deals with cases of aggravated tax evasion
and the laundering of aggravated tax fraud committed during
several transfers of football players between French clubs and
clubs playing in the Premier League. The UK authorities suspect
hidden payments to certain players, their agents or third
parties, allowing them to evade income taxes and social security
contributions. This judicial operation to combat tax fraud,
carried out jointly by the French and British authorities and
supervised by two PNF magistrates, took several months to prepare
and mobilised 32 investigators."
"HMRC has recently ‘discovered’ footballers as a soft target.
Something that has also been recently demonstrated in the Rangers
Supreme Court case and the enquiry into footballers’ image
rights,” said tax expert Tom Wesel, partner at Milestone
International Tax Consultants. “These raids could be a scare
tactic, forcing the clubs to negotiate over arrangements that
were entered into in good faith with professional advice. Or, the
clubs may have been daft enough to engage in what was obviously
fraud. We don’t know. Nor, perhaps, does HMRC yet.
“Powers to raid and seize documents have been hugely expanded in
recent years in very worrying ways - it’s at risk of degenerating
into a lawless envyfest."
Newcastle are yet to make an official statement but West Ham
have said they are "co-operating fully with HMRC to assist their
inquiries", subject to latest developments.
This is not the first time tax matters has been investigated in
football. Rangers football club, based in Scotland, will go to
the Supreme Court to find out whether a scheme called employee
benefit trusts, which offered loans to players, broke the law.
Rangers has had a checkered history over tax
affairs. Rangers, which traded under the name of The Rangers
Football Club plc, entered administration in February 2012, owing
money to the tax authority which subsequently refused to allow
Rangers to exit administration via a Company Voluntary
Arrangement. The Rangers Football Club went into liquidation on
31 October 2012. The situation meant administrators had to
sell the business and assets of Rangers to a new company,
operated by Charles Green. The other member clubs of the Scottish
Premier League refused to allow the new company to adopt the
league membership of the old company. After securing the Scottish
Football Association membership of the old company, Rangers (now
trading as The Rangers Football Club Ltd) entered the Third
Division in time for the 2012–13 season.
Barcelona star Lionel Messi was sentenced 21 months after being
found guilty for tax fraud. But he did not have to serve time in
jail because under the Spanish system, prison sentences of less
than two years can be served under probation.
The football body of the world, FIFA, was also embroiled in a
financial scandal in 2015, when US authorities investigated
nine FIFA officials and five corporate executives for
racketeering conspiracy and corruption. This lead to the former
president Sepp Blatter, who had been assailed in the media and
other outlets, resigning from his post.