Legal
BNP Paribas Admits Breaking US Sanctions, To Pay $8.97 Billion Fine
BNP Paribas, a bank with significant presence in global markets, such as Asia, as well as the US, has been hit with a record fine after an expected guilty plea for breaking US sanctions.
BNP Paribas, France's largest bank, has agreed to a record $8.97 billion settlement with US authorities, and has pleaded guilty on two criminal charges of violating US sanctions against Iran, Cuba and Sudan.
In early-afternoon trade today, shares in the bank were up 1.9 per cent, suggesting the market had expected a massive fine and punishment for some time and therefore yesterday's result provided a measure of certainty.
In a move that highlights the US view of the severity of the
case, the Paris-listed lender will be banned from clearing types
of transaction in US dollars for a year from the start of
2015.
“BNP Paribas today announced a comprehensive settlement of the
pending investigation relating to US dollar transactions
involving parties subject to US sanctions,” the bank said in a
statement late yesterday evening.
“The settlement includes guilty pleas entered into by BNP Paribas
SA in relation to violations of certain US laws and regulations
regarding economic sanctions against certain countries and
related recordkeeping,” it continued. The bank said it agreed to
pay a total of $8.97 billion. “Beyond what has already been
provisioned, this will result in an exceptional charge of €5.8
billion to be booked in the second quarter of 2014,” it said.
The bank said it also accepted a temporary suspension of one
year, starting 1 January 2015, of the dollar direct clearing
focused mainly the oil and gas energy and commodity finance
business in certain locations.
“Based on its estimates, BNP Paribas expects its fully-loaded
Basel III CET1 ratio as at 30 June 2014 to be at around 10 per
cent, consistent with the group’s targets announced within its
2014-2016 business development plan,” it continued. The firm said
it has designed “robust new compliance and control procedures”;
many of these are “now in place” and working effectively.
Holder
According to one account by the BBC, quoting US Attorney
General Eric Holder in a press conference in Washington DC,
during 2002 to 2014, BNP "engaged in complex and pervasive scheme
to illegally move billions through US financial system." In doing
so, the bank "deliberately and repeatedly violated longstanding
sanctions", he is quoted as saying.
This publication is in contact with the Paris-listed lender about
the matter. It had not received a reply at the time of going to
press. In recent weeks, BNP Paribas has not commented to this or
other publications when asked about specific details.
The scale of such a fine has already strained relations between
France and the US, possibly endangering talks on transatlantic
trade. The affair also has shone a harsh light on how countries
can clash on the severity of penalties for wrongdoing, a problem
at a time when international cooperation is essential in stamping
out money laundering and terrorism financing. However, the sheer
size of such a fine could add to perceptions that the US is
behaving as something of a "bully" in going after non-US banks
that break certain laws.
Reports had already warned that penalties on BNP Paribas could
involve a temporary ban on the bank’s ability to conduct
dollar-clearing activity, a move that is arguably as serious a
blow to the firm's business as the size of the fine. The size of
the fine is more than its entire annual profits last year.
One report noted that the head of BNP Paribas has written to
staff warning that the French banking giant will be fined heavily
by US authorities. "I want to be clear, we will be punished
severely," Jean-Laurent Bonnafe said in an internal memo.
Reports said said BNP Paribas, which has said it intends to
continue bolstering its wealth management activities in the US,
is expected to retain its banking licence from the New York state
banking regulator.
(Editor's note: no doubt in the days and weeks to come, there
will be considerable debate about the extent to which lessons
have, or in some cases, have not, been learned by banks and other
financial institutions about such breaches of rules. Even by the
standards of recent financial misdeeds and punishments, the US
action against the French bank is harsh. Banks such as HSBC and
Standard Chartered have been hit also in recent years. The US
clearly means business - but a question that needs to be
addressed is whether leading countries such as France, Germany,
the UK and US, among others, are on the same page in agreeing
what punishments and actions are fair, and what are not.)