Legal
US Firm Owned By Investment Legend Ordered To Pay Nearly $1 Million Over Antitrust Case

Berkshire Hathaway, owned by Warren Buffett, has agreed to pay a penalty for violating antitrust pre-merger notification requirements.
Berkshire
Hathaway, the multi-national investment and holding company
owned by billionaire Warren Buffet, has agreed to pay an $896,000
civil penalty for violating antitrust pre-merger notification
requirements when it acquired a Chicago-based construction
materials company last year.
Berkshire Hathaway, which is headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska,
said in a statement that it had agreed to pay a civil penalty of
$896,000 for failing to report the acquisition of an equity stake
in USG Corporation last December.
“We made a mistake when we overlooked the filing requirement,”
Buffet said in a statement.
The civil penalty, which requires court approval, settles charges
made on Wednesday by the US Department of Justice and Federal
Trade Commission that Berkshire violated the Hart-Scott-Rodino
antitrust law by failing to inform regulators about the
transaction in advance.
The Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976 requires
the Federal Trade Commission and Justice Department to be
notified of transactions where the total value exceeds $283.6
million.
“The commission requires compliance with the pre-merger
notification rules, and will not hesitate to seek civil penalties
against companies or individuals that fall short of their filing
responsibilities,” said Deborah Feinstein, director of the FTC’s
bureau of competition.
As a result of its acquisition of USG voting securities in
December 2013, Berkshire Hathaway held approximately 28 per cent
of the company, which was valued at more than $950 million.
According to the complaint made by the FTC, Berkshire Hathaway
changed convertible notes it owned in USG into 21.4 million
voting securities which exceeded the pre-merger reporting
threshold of $283.6 million. The company subsequently made a
corrective filing and acknowledged that the transaction should
have been reported in accordance with the Hart-Scott-Rodino
Antitrust Improvements Act.
Berkshire had owned convertible notes of USG since 2008. Buffet
said that the firm was “effectively forced” to convert the notes
when they were called for redemption by USG.
“This event triggered a filing requirement for Berkshire and we
were late in realising that fact,” said Buffet.
In June 2013, Berkshire Hathaway made a similar corrective filing
in connection with acquisition of $41 million of voting
securities in Symetra Financial Corporation, a transaction that
resulted in the firm exceeding the HSR Act’s threshold. On this
occasion, the FTC decided not to take action, but called on the
company to implement appropriate monitoring procedures going
forward.
“Although we may not seek penalties for every inadvertent error,
we will enforce the rules when the same party makes additional
mistakes after promises of improved oversight,” said
Feinstein.
According to Forbes Magazine, Buffet is the world’s
third richest person and widely considered the most successful
investor of the 20th century.
The American business magnate, also known as the "Wizard of
Omaha", turns 84 this month and oversees a conglomerate of more
than 80 businesses. The company wholly owns GEICO car insurance,
Dairy Queen, Fruit of the Loom and Helzberg Diamonds, half of
Heinz, an undisclosed percentage of Mars, as well as significant
minority holdings in American Express and Wells Fargo.