Investment Strategies
Quality’s Comeback Is An Earnings Story

Share prices eventually follow corporate earnings, regardless of whether a business is fashionable or not. The author explores how there could be a switch taking place in how investors view market opportunities.
The following article looks at the “quality” of companies as investors, mindful of the volatility of current equity markets, seek reassurance. The author of this piece is Chris Elliott (pictured below), who is portfolio manager of the Evenlode Global Equity Fund. Elliott is based in Oxford in the UK.
The editors are pleased to share this content and welcome readers to join the conversation. The usual editorial disclaimers apply. To comment, email tom.burroughes@wealthbriefing.com and amanda.cheesley@clearviewpublishing.com
Chris Elliott
In recent years, owning profitable, cash-generative and lightly
indebted businesses felt deeply unfashionable. Momentum stocks
carried all before them, and anyone who dared to ask about
returns on capital was rebuked that they had missed the point; it
was different this time.
Then, in July, we saw the first glimpse of a turn. The same
quality-minus-junk measure rose 14.3 per cent in a single month,
its biggest gain since 1957. Crowded momentum trades cracked and
investors started looking again at what companies were
earning.
But for us, this was in the post. The second-quarter reporting
season, which wrapped up at the end of August, gave the clearest
evidence in some time that the fundamentals had been there all
along.
Across our portfolio, our companies delivered average organic
revenue growth of 7.1 per cent and operating profit growth of
10.8 per cent. Strip out Nintendo, riding a console cycle, and
Clarkson, which benefited from disruption to Middle East
shipping, and the figures are 7.3 per cent and 7.8 per cent. That
is steady cash compounding, precisely what the market had
stopped paying for.
Against expectations, the picture was better still. Of the 29
holdings with sell-side consensus, 25 beat on operating profit
and 22 on revenue, and none of the seven revenue misses
were larger than 2 per cent. When supposedly unfashionable
businesses beat their numbers this consistently, it gave us
another signal that perhaps the market had become a little
too fixated on shiny new objects.
AI hasn’t eaten their lunch
Nowhere was the gap between narrative and reality wider than in
information services. For much of the past two years, the market
has written off RELX, one of the few genuine UK technology
champions, along with Wolters Kluwer and Verisk, on the
assumption that a frontier model could replicate what they sell
for a fraction of the price.
This quarter the fightback began. Erik Engstrom, chief executive
of RELX, said 90 per cent of the value of new sales now comes
from its AI-enabled platform. Adoption of the UpToDate AI product
at Wolters Kluwer keeps accelerating, and Verisk has grown Xact
AI licences tenfold since March, albeit from a low base.
Our view has always been that the value of these services is in
the data, not the model. Jeffrey Sprecher, chief executive of
Intercontinental Exchange, put it more bluntly than I could: “The
model is the commodity.” Proprietary data, embedded workflows and
decades of trust are what a model needs to be useful. AI widens
that advantage rather than eroding it.
Good management shows most clearly when something goes wrong.
Honeywell Aerospace, in its first quarter as an independent
company, was candid about supply chain bottlenecks: roughly 2 per
cent of its more than 3,000 suppliers are critical or
constrained. It quadrupled spending on multi-sourcing and
in-sourcing and second-sourced more than 50 suppliers in the
first half. Inside a conglomerate, that response would have been
far slower.
At Diageo, new chief executive Dave Lewis has set out a
turnaround built on scaling Guinness, reclaiming ground in
ready-to-drink and taking out cost. The road back is not easy,
but he has clearly energised the business. Hasbro, meanwhile,
cancelled several planned video games, which is the sort of
capital allocation discipline that seldom gets the credit it
deserves.
Why the rally can last
Not everything went our way. CH Robinson posted excellent
operating results, including a 96 per cent incremental operating
margin, only to see them overshadowed by an adverse legal ruling
whose ultimate cost is still unclear. The New York
Times admitted that it is getting less traffic from the big
platforms.
History is a reasonable guide to previous cycles. After each of
the three previous technology-driven speculative
cycles, 1960s electronics, the dotcom boom and the 2020 rush
into electric vehicles, crypto and remote work, quality beat
lower-quality stocks by between 28 per cent and 68 per cent over
the following two years. Goldman Sachs also finds that quality
tends to lead once earnings expectations start to be revised
down, which is where much of the market now appears to be
heading.
I won’t pretend to know when the next rotation will come. Factor
leadership is fickle, and September showed how quickly sentiment
can swing back towards momentum. But the past few months have
reminded investors that share prices eventually follow earnings,
no matter how unfashionable. And quality companies earned it,
quarter by quarter, while very few were watching.