Alt Investments
Investment Market For Fine Wine Slightly Soured In 2015

Fine wine has drawn plenty of attention as a "passion investment", but a measure of prices for some of the greatest wines declined slightly in 2015.
Well, the data is in. Investors in the world’s most renowned
wines from regions such as Bordeaux didn’t make money in most
areas last year, although this won’t necessarily reduce the
thirst to take a punt on fortunes of the noble grape just
yet.
Liv—ex, the online exchange tracking prices fetched at auctions
for fine wines, says that its Liv-ex Fine Wine 100 benchmark of
auction deals was down 0.1 per cent in 2015, and has fallen 29.15
per cent over the past five years. The narrower Liv-ex Fine Wine
50 measure is down 33.96 per cent over five years and fell 0.73
per cent last year. The Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000 measure did a bit
better, up by just 0.6 per cent last year, but is down over five
years.
To some extent, the slippage of last year isn’t as severe as the
performance of mainstream equity markets, so this might – just –
give some credence to the idea that fine wine investments
can diversify a portfolio, although it does not necessarily
reduce asset class correlations all that much. The MSCI World
Index of developed countries’ shares was down 0.9 per cent in
2015.
Consumers hoping that some of the astronomic prices fetched by
renowned houses might be coming back towards Earth have some
cause for cheer. Liv-ex says in its commentary that the Liv-ex
Bordeaux 500 index fell 10.7 per cent from 2010. Last year,
Bordeaux’s share of the total fine wine market fell to levels not
seen since 2004 before the China-led bull market and the sharp
boom, and then bust, in Bordeaux prices. Elsewhere, Italy,
Champagne and the rest of the world have all seen their
percentage of trade share increase. So looking ahead, there may
be some grounds, Liv-ex says, for seeing this as opportunity to
re-enter the Bordeaux market.
As Liv-ex notes, China has been a large driver of spending on
fine wines in recent years; the worries about the country’s stock
market and some deceleration to its GDP growth might dent demand
for wine from that quarter, although price changes may have
already anticipated some of that eventuality. The “Asia factor”
in wine remains quite a potent one, at least as far as some firms
are concerned. As reported recently, the UK-headquartered firm
Cult Wines has set up an office in Hong Kong to exploit continued
demand for wine and associated investment.