Legal
HSBC Applauds Five-Year Jail Term For Ex-Employee Who Took Data From Swiss Bank

The "whistleblower" who took data from HSBC's private bank in the Alpine state has been sentenced to five years in jail - although the man is in France and is unlikely to see the inside of a prison.
The former employee of HSBC at the centre of a scandal over secret accounts at its Swiss private banking arm has been sentenced to five years in jail by a Swiss court, a move praised by the Hong Kong/London-listed banking group today.
Hervé Falciani, who had worked for HSBC's Geneva private bank and
who leaked information on clients and their tax affairs, was
sentenced today but did not attend the trial and is based in
France.
“HSBC welcomes the decision of the Swiss Federal Criminal Court
to sentence former IT employee Hervé Falciani to five years in
prison for aggravated industrial espionage,” the bank said in a
statement.
“HSBC has always maintained that Falciani systematically stole
clients’ information in order to sell it for his own personal
financial gain. The court heard that he was not motivated by
whistleblowing intentions and that this was not a victimless
crime,” it continued.
HSBC disputed Falciani’s claim to be a whistleblower about
undeclared accounts, claiming he tried to sell client account
information for financial gain. The former employee’s leak of
client account details has prompted a number of governments, such
as those in the UK and France, to investigate. The bank has
claimed that since 2008, it has sharply reduced the number of
persons using accounts at the private bank, with a consequent cut
in assets under management. It is understood that a large number
of accounts affected by Falciani’s activities were closed more
than a decade ago. The case also highlights the problem of how a
person can raise questions about alleged wrongdoing in a bank
when secrecy laws expressly forbid bankers from disclosing their
clients’ identities.
The leak of client data and the media storm around it were
embarrassing to the bank. HSBC’s group chief executive, Stuart
Gulliver, took out full-page advertisements in the UK press
earlier this year to apologise over the matter. The controversy
broke shortly before the UK general election in May, when the
issue of whether wealthy persons were avoiding or evading taxes
was high on the public agenda.
Falciani may not serve any time in a Swiss prison because, as
media reports said, France typically does not extradite its own
citizens, and there are no legal proceedings against him in
France.
Falciani's lawyer - Marc Henzelin - did not immediately respond
to a request for a comment, according to Reuters.
The case has added to pressure on Switzerland’s bank secrecy
laws, which make it a serious crime for bank employees to divulge
information about their clients’ identities. A number of
cross-border tax treaties between Switzerland and major
industrialised nations are widely held to spell the practical
demise of these laws, although they remain on the country’s
statute books.
To see a recent editorial comment on bank secrecy in Switzerland,
click here.