Print this article
As Asset Management Recovery Begins, Traditional Players Lose Out - BCG Report
Sandra Kilhof
11 July 2013
After four years of stalled growth, the $62 trillion global
asset management industry has nearly returned its profits to pre-crisis levels,
says a new report from the Boston Consulting Group. However, the recovery isn’t
clear for traditional managers in the industry’s largest asset pools, as
investor preferences shift towards non-traditional options. According to BCG’s study of the worldwide asset-management
industry, total assets under management rose to $62.4 trillion in 2012,
surpassing the 2007 record of $57.2 trillion. Operating margins rose to 37 per
cent of net revenues, while profit increased to $80 billion, remaining 15 per cent
below levels measured prior to the financial crisis. The growth in AuM clearly reflects a recovery largely driven
by the rise of global equity and fixed-income markets, the report said. This
shifting investment focus has in turn pushed up the value of securities
underlying managers’ assets, rather than by net new asset flows. Likewise, the
increase in new asset flows remained relatively modest, totalling just 1.2 per cent
of global AuM in 2012. A key finding of the report is the structural shift which
the market is currently undergoing. Most new flows have moved to solutions,
specialties, and passive asset classes, providing growth in the non-traditional
sector and outpacing traditional actively-managed core assets. Meanwhile, 25 per cent of
traditional managers even reported significant erosion of their core-asset base
in 2012, despite the broad recovery of AuM. “That ongoing structural shift has heightened questions
about the future of traditional managers,” said Gary Shub, BCG partner and co-author
of the report. “For the remaining traditional managers, the urgent need for
change is obscured by strong revenues from the installed asset base, but
investment in new higher-growth capabilities is no less critical.” In this light, the report suggests that traditional managers
become "ambidextrous" and stabilise their existing core asset base while broadening
their scope of investments to new faster-growth assets, such as solutions and
specialties. In this part of the sector, specialists and ambidextrous players
have enjoyed a 10 per cent profit increase per annum since 2012, while
traditional players saw yearly profit losses of 2 per cent in the same period. Major markets players have especially benefited from following
the trend towards non-traditional products. In the report’s top 10 ranking of
asset managers in the US and
Europe, it is clear that focusing a majority
of investments on specialties across equity and fixed income, has boosted
revenue levels considerably. Furthermore, firms are increasingly looking at bringing down
costs, as traditional core assets are eroding. With a growing need for industry
players to invest in capabilities the BCG report recommends tightly managing the cost structure in order to free up assets. “Reviewing the operating model, with a focus on operations
and IT, is a growing source of strategic advantage,” said Brent Beardsley, a co-author
and BCG partner, who is global leader of the firm’s asset and wealth management
segment. “Beyond boosting efficiency, a review can be the key to
flexibility, scalability, and future growth.” The report, which covers more than 98 per cent of the global
asset management business, also revealed disparities in regional market
developments. Having focused on speciality capabilities, US-based asset
managers outperformed European counterparts, with US profits rising 10 per cent above
2007 levels. In comparison, European managers’ profits remained 31 per cent
below pre-crisis levels. In this respect, asset managers continue to confront a
two-speed world in which the smaller, rapidly developing markets grow faster
than the developed markets, with higher net flows. At the same time, AuM growth
in the developed markets was significantly greater in absolute terms because of
the dominant size of those markets. AuM growth was especially noticeable in Asia, excluding Japan and Australia, which saw a 17 per cent
increase in 2012. Latin America also performed strongly with 14 per cent growth
in assets under management, while the Middle East and South Africa
grew 12 per cent. According to BCG, the study covered 120 leading industry
players managing a total $33 trillion, or 53 per cent of global AuM.