Print this article
Guest Comment: There Are "Green Shoots" On View In Russia - Renaissance
Jesse Sherman
Renaissance Asset Managers
1 October 2012
Editor’s note: Below
is commentary from Jesse Sherman, part of the investment team for emerging Europe at Renaissance Asset Managers. He is talking
about the prospects for Russia.
As ever, while this publication is pleased to use this material, the views
expressed here are the author’s own. The news out of Russia over the last ten months has
been pretty grim. Pictures of Russian protest rallies vied with articles
detailing allegations of election fraud and the sentencing of three members of
the punk band Pussy Riot, which prompted widespread condemnation. On the corporate front, BP is doing battle with its Russian
partners Alfa Access Renova (AAR) in TNK-BP as part of the British company’s
second attempt to tie up with state-owned Rosneft. And President Vladimir
Putin’s electrifying election promise to move Russia up 100 places in the World
Bank’s “Doing Business” survey to 20th by 2018 seems to have fallen on deaf
ears. Investors are clearly fed up with the headlines and have
become inured to promises of change by years of stalled reforms and perceived
empty promises. So, where do we go from here? Despite market sentiment being at an all-time low, the
“green shoots” of improved corporate governance and market reform are there if
you want to see them. How far we’ve
travelled First and foremost, it is important to note how far the
Russian market has progressed. Not that long ago the standard practice for
companies was financial statements in Russian only, limited access to
management, and neither investor relations departments nor result conference
calls. Today, nearly every major company issues quarterly/semi-annual
statements (in English) to international accounting standards, investor relations
is a well-developed expertise, and management teams visit investors multiple
times a year on road shows in addition to participating in innumerable
conferences. More improvement is in the works, as all Russian listed companies
will be required to produce IFRS results in 2013. And the changes are not limited to the private sector. Over
the past couple of years, we’ve seen state-controlled companies rationing
investment spending and increasing free cash flow generation. The Russian
government has applied further pressure to increase efficiency, requiring a
minimum 25 per cent dividend payout on RAS financial accounts, which could soon
be applied to IFRS results, perhaps raising the payout even higher. While there are many market reforms underway, the most
important is the long-awaited establishment of a Russian Central Depository
this autumn. Fixed-income securities will feel the impact first, but the
long-term benefits will reach equity markets over the next few years. Greater
transparency and market depth will be helped by the requirement to disclose
ultimate beneficiaries in order to receive dividends and in the medium term by
the expected fungibility of local shares and depository receipts. Almost unnoticed by the market, Russia finally became a member of
the World Trade Organisation after 18 years of negotiations on 22 August – the
last member of the G8 to join. While Russia’s
accession is unlikely to have the profound impact that WTO membership had on China in 2001,
this is still an important milestone in the country’s history. In the short
term, Russia’s
exporters are expected to gain immediately from the lowering of trade barriers
by as much as $1.5-2 billion per annum, and lower tariffs on imports are
expected to drive increasing consumer power and spending. In the long term, the
change could be transformational as Russian companies feel the heat of full and
unfettered competition. Even the government is slowly starting to clean up its act
after then-president and now Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev required all government
officials to step down as board members of state-run entities in 2011.
Currently, new draft laws are under discussion by the Duma that will require state
employees to disclose their offshore assets and maybe even limit ownership of
such assets. While Russia still has to travel a long road before its
corporate governance and market reforms can be considered on a par with its
global peers, the “green shoots” are already breaking through. In our view, the
question is more an issue of when rather than if. Clearly, Russia’s
year-to-date stock market performance of +10.2 per cent vs. +15.7 per cent for
the MSCI World and +32.4 per cent for Turkey presents a tremendous
opportunity.