Print this article
UK Lawmakers Give "Tobin Tax" Short Shrift
Tom Burroughes
5 December 2011
A financial transactions tax, sometimes dubbed a “Robin Hood”
tax by its supporters, would cost the UK
economy up to 20 times more than the revenues it would raise, lawmakers in the UK parliament
said last week. The idea of a FTT, which is also sometimes named a Tobin Tax
after the US
economist who came up with the idea in the 1970s, would only work if it is enforced around
the world, an EU Sub-Committee on Economic and Financial Affairs and International Trade in the House of Lords said. The UK
government, such as finance minister George Osborne, has attacked the notion of
an FTT, arguing that it will have a disproportionate effect on London
as a financial centre, because London
accounts for more turnover than the rest of the European Union’s member
financial centres put together. "The FTT is likely to induce a loss in GDP between five
and 20 times larger than the revenues raised from the tax," the committee,
which is part of the upper chamber of the parliament, said. "We remain to be convinced that such a tax would either reduce instability in the market or prevent another financial crisis," it said. There are concerns that if such a tax is levied in only one
region of the world, it will push banks and other financial intermediaries to
transfer trading activities to other locations. As an example of such a transfer of activity, in the late 1960s, a US levy called the Interest Equalization Tax was
regarded as driving a large offshore dollar market to London at the time. There are also concerns
that an FTT will reduce market liquidity and hence increase volatility rather
than reduce it. To view a recent opinion piece on the idea of such a tax,
click here.