Print this article
Analysis: Risk Management Across The Generations
Amy Buttell
3 October 2011
For most high net worth
families, the biggest issues surrounding risk management across the
generations were minimizing taxes and controlling or at least
influencing how that wealth would be used and managed in the future.
Principal preservation was a distant third on the list of priorities. That was until the
financial crisis of 2008. “In 2008 and 2009 we had a real monetary
banking system, money market-related, debt-related sense of crisis,”
says Hinton Crawford, head of private investment counsel for TD
Wealth, the investment management arm of TD Bank. “Investment banks
and banks that had been around for a long time were failing or close
to failing. So the high net worth investor became concerned, for
really the first time in many years, that his or her wealth could be
at risk.” This defining moment –
the financial crisis of 2008-09 – shifted the focus of the
conversation between high net worth families with multi-generational
wealth from how to distribute and protect wealth to how to preserve
it, he continues. “If you start worrying that your principal might
not be there in the future, that puts the question of passing it
along to future generations in perspective,” he adds. Wealth managers were
faced with the issue of re-educating their clients about risk
management in an investment portfolio in a time of great stress.
While it was important to talk to clients about investment risk
management, the focus on that area couldn’t distract other
professionals on the wealth management team from their jobs of
handling risks in other areas such as insurance, taxes, cash flow,
etc. Like Crawford, Eric
Dunavant, principal at Dunavant Wealth Group in Mandeville, LA, finds
that he’s been spending more time educating clients about
securities selection, asset allocations, buy and sell disciplines and
portfolio management. “We’ve become more active than reaction in
terms of talking to clients about what we’re doing,” he says.
“We’re doing more reviews and reminding our clients that they
hired us to be more proactive in managing their investments and
portfolios and many find that very comforting. One gentleman actually
told us he is sleeping better at night.” Christine Walker, chief
risk officer of Farmers and Merchants Trust Company in Newport Beach,
CA and fifth-generation member of a high net worth family, believes
that education is one of the most important components in terms of
helping wealth families and their heirs understand their investments
and their responsibilities to past and future generations. An
important part of the Walker family’s stewardship of their wealth
and the community institutions they are involved with – which
include the Farmers and Merchants Trust Company and the Farmers and
Merchants Bank – is conserving assets for the future. “My
great-grandfather went to work every day until he was 92 and he lived
through the Great Depression, which taught him, and he in turn taught
us, to be conservative with your wealth and especially not
over-leverage,” she adds. “It’s important that family members
understand where their family money comes from, how it’s invested
and why it’s invested the way it is. Education is key.” When talking to
clients, Crawford’s focus is to explain what is going on in the
global economy, why it’s happening and where the areas of actual
risk exist. Once clients understand what is going on and why and what
risks their portfolio faces, the conversation moves onto how these
risks impact their portfolio and whether there should be any changes
to how it’s managed. “That could mean
moving from money market funds, which have potential exposure to
foreign banks, to US Treasuries or US government money market funds
or whether it means having a larger proportion of liquid assets in
the portfolio, you have a discussion about that and the
implications,” he says. “All these issues are related to managing
risk and getting clients comfortable with the idea that they will get
through this.” Showing clients that
you have a disciplined process that you apply to portfolio management
in good times and bad helps reassure them that risk levels are being
appropriately managed in their portfolio, no matter what is happening
in the markets, notes Dunavant. His practice implemented a new
discipline regarding buy sell decisions that has taken the emotional
out of the decision, whether from the client or the advisor. “It’s a challenge
right now in this environment to not chase returns, and having a
clearly articulated sell discipline restrains that and informs the
clients where we are coming from and that we have a process,” he
says. “Right now we are in the protected mode, where we are trying
to protect client portfolios and that is how we are managing
portfolio risk right now, via a clear sell discipline.” Another conversation
that is occurring around risk management is the question of
investment yield, notes Crawford. “In this low interest rate
environment, interest from investments is significantly lower that it
was in the past and many high net worth families who pass wealth
through the generations get to the point where the second and third
generations are very dependent on interest income to maintain their
lifestyle,” he says. Educating clients about
the potential interest rate risk is important, he continues, so that
they understand what is happening and what the options are within the
portfolio to generate income. “One option is structured products,
that we offer in conjunction with TD Asset Management that will
provide a reasonable amount of income and not move in concert with
financial markets.” In the end, educating
high net worth clients with multi-generational wealth about whatever
your process is around risk management pays dividends. By spending
time doing that, you can cement your value proposition with the
entire family, Crawford says. “Once the clients understand what you
offer and have been with you a while, they look at that as a
significant value add, so it’s worth taking the time to do,” he
adds.