Print this article
Renaissance Upbeat On Eastern Europe, Equities
Tom Burroughes
3 June 2011
Optimism is not in fashion with so much geopolitical turbulence
and fears over sovereign debt but at least one fund manager says the future is bright –
in the emerging economies of Eastern Europe. Renaissance Asset Managers have a number of funds that gain
exposure to the equity markets of Eastern Europe, including those of Russia,
one of the perhaps less fashionable BRICs. And Karol Chrystowski, portfolio
manager for the Renaissance Emerging Europe Fund and Renaissance Emerging Europe
Long-Short Fund, is upbeat. “Where I think I differ from the market is that the market
is in the bearish camp,” he told this publication in a recent interview. “We take a completely different view: the second half of
this year will be a strong bull market, especially in the East European
market,” he said, adding that a bull phase will extend for at least another two
years, if historical experience is a reliable guide. “Pretty much every bull cycle lasts about four years; we have
in the US a bond yield curve that it is exceptionally steep,” he said, noting
that this is typically positive for stocks. “Valuations are not stretched at all, one could
argue that equities are the cheapest assets one could buy in the world these
days,” he said, pointing out that the S&P 500 index of US stocks is trading
at roughly 12-13 times expected earnings at present. Finally, constant
bearishness is actually very positive as bull markets of highest quality are
built on insecurity. Once investors become consensually confident it will be a
big warning signal to start taking profits,” he continued. His funds are new: The long-only portfolio, launched in
October last year, holds around $50 million of client money and is available in
a UCITS structure; the long-short hedge fund is still in fund-raising mode,
with less than $10 million of assets. The fund is registered in Luxembourg and priced in dollars. Given the shortness of its life so far, performance data on
the long-only fund should be treated carefully. Since inception, it has delivered returns of 14.1 per cent,
slightly lagging the benchmark of Morgan Stanley Capital International 10/40
Emerging Europe index of equities. There is, however, plenty of time and
opportunity for the fund to deliver out-performance. Renaissance is by no means the only such fund manager
operating in this space and providing porfolios for wealthy clients. Probably
one of the best known managers of emerging market funds, with deep experience
in Eastern Europe, is Mark Mobius, at Templeton.
Other firms with such funds are T Rowe Price, FIM; Ashmore and Jupiter Asset
Management. Investors who want to track a broad market index rather than buy an
actively run portfolio can hold exchange traded funds, such as the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Eastern Europe
Index Fund. Macro and micro Renaissance has advanced macro-economic models to address
changes in the global economy. The fund uses a mix of top-down macro economic
analysis and bottom-up stock specific analysis, said Chrystowski, who has been
at Renaissance for just over a year. “I may find a very interesting company on a stand-alone
basis in terms of valuation, management and prospects but if the top-down model
says this country is going to enter a nasty period for some reason, we are
unlikely to enter the space. The same works the other way around,” he said. “The picture we like most is when both arrows are pointing
in the same direction - we are prepared then to make decisive bets, regardless
what regional benchmark says in terms of weights," he said. “Where I think we are different from our competitors is that
we are aware of the benchmark but we use it more to notice what competitors are
doing but we have no problem in departing from that benchmark quite
substantially,” he continued. “The benchmark tends, for reasons of liquidity and size, to
be skewed towards larger, liquid stocks at the expense of relatively smaller
ones. The problem is that the great majority of those mega caps are concentrated
around energy and commodities - industries where performance is a reflection of
Chinese investment cycle much more than specific stories and opportunities of Eastern Europe,” said Chrystowski. “We benefit from the fact that we have a small fund,” he
said, pointing out that it is easier for a small fund to play in purely Eastern
European growth stories than for a fund over $1 billion or more. How big could the long-only fund become? “The long-only fund could reach the region of around $1.0
billion; of course, that could change if the market grows a bit in terms of
liquidity and capacity,” he replied.